! Choose language
選擇你的語言
close  
 Language 

公告

  • I work at alivenotdead.com. Please check out my blogs and leave a comment!

BLOG

  • 少林少女 review - what the hell where they thinking?

    2008-06-07 1:47AM / 標準BLOG / Asian Movie Review / 會員可以看
    24個評論


    Decided to go see 'Shaolin Girl'(少林少女) at the last minute after I got home from work the other night.  In case you're not familiar,  'Shaolin Girl' is a Japanese movie that was co-produced by Stephen Chow, creator of the worldwide hit 'Shaolin Soccer'...  
    [btw - Shaolin Soccer was a hit in Japan as well... its one of the few HK movies that most of my regular Japanese friends know...]

    Click for japanese trailer





    Shaolin Girl is similar to Shaolin Soccer in that it revolves around a girl named Rin (played by Japanese singer/actress Shibasaki Kou)  with super powerful Shaolin Martial arts ability trying to do sports,  in this case lacrosse (I didn't even know they had lacrosse in Japan!?!) --  so you get some cool visuals of people playing sports using super human powers to shoot balls at super-sonic speeds, glowing w/ fire and qi, etc etc. 


    It even features two of the Shaolin brothers from Shaolin Soccer, the qinggong fat guy and the iron shirt glasses guy.... but more importantly, it also has Kitty Zhang, who you may have seen in Stephen Chow's recent film 'CJ7'....


    gah!  actually she has a lot more screen time in this film then she does in CJ7 - she plays a Chinese exchange student who befriends Rin and introduces her to the lacrosse team at the nearby university...


    (before you ask - no, I didn't just go see this movie to see cute Japanese college girls in Lacrosse uniforms...)

    OK, should be a safe bet for a film though, right?  Take a proven funny idea and remake it with funny actors, attractive girls... how can you go wrong?  Well it wasn't easy, but apparently they found a way to turn it into a POS!


    The story gets convoluted with a strange evil university president as the main antagonist...  although I never really figured out what the hell he was trying to do with his evilness...  

    The movie started out shakily,  but it was on its formulaic way until we get to the second half - at that point it departs from the Shaolin Soccer story and turns into a strange martial arts action film, in which the girl has to fight through a pagoda of thugs to try to save Kitty Zhang from the evil university president (who's hobby is apparently fighting people with karate and then retiring to his evil 'Game of Death'-style Pagoda on campus. I think it was trying to ALSO copy Kungfu Hustle at this point, right down to the costume:


    Anyway, at this point in the film I was so confused and annoyed...  "what the hell were they thinking?" kept popping up in my head... it was like this was supposed to be two separate poorly conceived plots, and they decided to combine them into one...  people in the audience just started groaning audibly towards the end too...

    After about 30-45 minutes of this she finally defeats the bad guy, saves Kitty Zhang and everyone's happy.  I'm thinking 'So wait, what happened to the Lacrosse stuff?!? I guess they gave up on that....'  but then suprisingly just as the credits come up,  they show a super long montage of scenes of the team going all the way to the finals and winning the championship before huge giant sell-out crowds (similar to the last 1/2 of Shaolin Scocer... except at this point its already during the end credits!)  -- production cost wise I was even more puzzled,  it seemed like they spent a LOT of time and money making all those scenes for 2-3 minutes worth of footage during the closing credits...

    Here's a few examples:


    NOTE: All of these scenes occur during the credits after the movie is OVER...

    What the hell were they thinking? I'm just guessing, but perhaps something weird must have happened during the production of this movie like the director quit or the movie company sent it back for a complete rewrite half-way through...

    Lesson of the Day: If you're going to make a knock off of Shaolin Soccer,  just follow the formula and remake a sports movie...  don't suddenly switch gears and try to ALSO remake Kungfu Hustle and put them in the SAME movie...

    Oh,  before I forget, let me also point out that they had some Japanese actors playing Shaolin monks in the beginning with absolutely atrocious Mandarin...  can't believe they didn't dub them over.... I think they did dub over Kitty Zhang's voice for the Japanese...

    And last but not least, as a martial arts enthusiast, the other major problem was the fact that few, if any, of the actors had much of a martial arts background...  some of the stances and poses were quite bad.  They try to use CG and wires to cover up during the fight scenes...  with mixed results.

    anyway, I'll give it a 3/10...  I think I can only recommend it for the fact that Kitty Zhang is in there. :-P

BLOG評論 (24)

  • 添加評論請先登錄免費註冊
  • Etchy
     
    留言於2008-06-11 1:27PM
    jason - i don't blame them for being in the movie,  i blame the movie for screwing itself up so badly! :-P
  • JasonJason
    留言於2008-06-11 6:30AM [举报]
    Lam Chi Chung on the left and Tin Kai Man on the right. I guess you can't really blame 'em for being in this, especially now that Stephen Chow's making fewer movies. I mean even Yuen Qiu and Yuen Wah were in the dreadful cash-in movie Kung Fu Mahjong... and Kung Fu Mahjong 2...and Kung Fu Mahjong 3:"The Final Duel" LOL!
  • AsianChick100
    留言於2008-06-09 11:21PM [举报]
    yeah, the reviews echo yours... =/ i guess this one can wait  (DVD)...
  • Etchy
     
    留言於2008-06-09 3:39AM
    no, probably not that bad.   its almost decent, thats the problem...
  • xibanyae
    留言於2008-06-09 1:17AM [举报]
    now, this movie cannot be worse than "wulin zuqiu" (武林足球)! (aka "soccer king")
    that is one of the worse movies of all times!

    http://data.movie.xunlei.com/movie/38787
  • amy_sycheng
    留言於2008-06-08 6:35PM [举报]
    Thks for the info.  I love Japanese TV series/ movies, even it seems that everyone is going to watch Korean films!
  • xibanyae
    留言於2008-06-07 10:27PM [举报]
    i am with etchy on this one, kitty! kitty! ;)
  • Etchy
     
    留言於2008-06-07 9:26PM
    andy - she's ok, but she's no Kitty Zhang...
  • andy_lau_spain
    留言於2008-06-07 8:36PM [举报]
    I wanna watch it out of curiosiry...and..er...okay..yeah, for Shibasaki too...but I dun have high expectations from it ^^U
    (she was SO cute in Dororo >")<
  • Etchy
     
    留言於2008-06-07 7:18PM
    she's not the problem! ;-)
  • JoanneSanderson
    留言於2008-06-07 5:13PM [举报]
    Shibasaki looks completely different to the films I remember her from, she's not a bad actress, shame about the movie though, but I guess everyone makes a poor movie choice.
  • Etchy
     
    留言於2008-06-07 2:03PM
    no, i already own several videos full of that... no need.
  • rottendoubt
     
    留言於2008-06-07 1:56PM [举报]
    Did you just go see this movie to see cute Japanese college girls in Lacrosse uniforms?
  • Etchy
     
    留言於2008-06-07 10:13AM
    its supposed to be cheesy,  i mean its all set to be a stereotypical sports movie... but the problem is they don't even get that right...
  • unwoundclock
    留言於2008-06-07 9:50AM [举报]
    shaolin girl sounds cheesy.. id never watch it..
  • RenRen
    留言於2008-06-07 5:30AM [举报]
    Hmm...I've never watched a movie about lacrosse before. You made it sound so bad, I don't think I'll ever watch it.
  • peachey
    留言於2008-06-07 2:53AM [举报]
    It's a tale about friendship with a mish-mash of other stuff.
  • Etchy
     
    留言於2008-06-07 2:17AM
    xibanyae - yes, its at least unique... we have enough gigi's... :-P
  • an_aoii
    留言於2008-06-07 2:14AM [举报]
    your main job is make trailer and poster for new movie ?
  • xibanyae
    留言於2008-06-07 2:09AM [举报]
    "kitty" zhang? what an english name she chose!? :D
  • 241/212>
Etchy 邀請你瀏覽他/她的空間。趕緊註冊,創建你自己的空間,跟好友及喜愛的電影工作者、音樂家及其他藝術家交流。