Forbidden Kingdom Review

公告

I work at alivenotdead.com. Please check out my blogs and leave a comment!

BLOG

上一個BLOG |

下一個BLOG |

全部

2008-05-05 9:27AM / 標準BLOG / US Movie Review / 會員可以看
13個評論

CURRENT RATINGS:

7/10

Movie:

The Forbidden Kingdom (2008)

The long awaited collaboration between the two biggest names in martial arts cinema... The problem with a movie like this is that invariably the anticipation will be uber high and no matter what, people will be disappointed. I think Jet and Jackie anticipated this and specifically made an attempt to limit expectations in advance via their blogs...

note, this scene does not actually apear in this movie...

The fact is that this film is a US production, about an American teenager who gets magically transported from modern times into a mythical Chinese past - on a mission to return a magical staff to the Monkey King (and bring order to the world... of course).

In that respect this movie reminded me a lot of similar 'fairy tale' type movies aimed at youth audiences.... think the 1980 'Flash Gordon' or Arnold's 'Last Action Hero' and maybe a bit of Narnia too... all of which are not great cinema, but they have some redeeming qualities that make them entertaining to watch. I went into this movie only expecting something along those lines and I was actually pleasantly surprised, it was better than I expected.

Definitely cheesy at points, the production quality was pretty decent, the scenery of course was breathtaking.

Except i think they filmed some of the desert scenes in the exact same place as 'Escape from Huang Shi'.

But I thought that the martial arts was what set this apart from those average children's fantasy films... There is actually quite a lot of fighting and for the most part its pretty well done. In that respect I think people who are going just for the fighting won't be too disappointed.

Actually the action kind of surprised me. This film is actually more 'violent' than a lot of Jackie's movies and more violent than other 'youth action' fantasy type films. People getting chopped w/ swords and what not.

The supporting cast is good too, Li Bingbing, Collin Chou and Liu Yifei are all entertaining enough to keep your eyes fixed on the screen even when there's no fighting going on. And Yuen Woo Ping (and some stunt doubles) do a good job keeping up with Jet and Jackie in the action department too.

But I have to say, as an American who practice(d) chinese martial arts for over 10 years and enjoys Asian cinema quite a bit, I can tell that the screen play was written by/for an American fans of 'kung fu cinema' rather than for the average Chinese or HK movie goer.... the Chinese mythology is all kind of mashed together and there's Bruce Lee and Shaw Brothers references sprinkled in.... In the theater in HK we watched it in, there were some people laughing at the unintentionally funny parts, but that happens with films that take themselves much more seriously too...

In Conclusion - I think this movie is worth checking out, but please don't expect Drunken Master vs Wong Fei Hung. I'll give it a 7/10 as a martial arts fantasy. Jet and Jackie should have made this movie 10 or 15 years ago, let's hope we don't have to wait 10 more for another one!

ps - to quote Ken Brockman from 'Tale of Two Springfields' - "We are all taking golden showers!"

BLOG評論 (13)

添加評論請先登錄或免費註冊
NicoleLai
留言於2008-05-07 8:32AM [举报]

ehhhhhhhhh not at all interested
Etchy
留言於2008-05-07 12:20AM

senh - yes exactly... they did the minimum required to make it worth the trouble, everything else wasn't that big a deal.
senhman
留言於2008-05-06 10:44PM [举报]

Jackie and Jet's fight scene together was pretty damn good. After that, everything else was gravy.
JoanneSanderson
留言於2008-05-05 5:05PM [举报]

I prefer the heavily influenced Asian martial arts movies to the ones designed for western viewers, but there ain't a chance in hell I'm missing this, It's been a long time coming.
Etchy
留言於2008-05-05 2:52PM

jane: yeah it worth going to see, just as a martial arts based 'popcorn' summer movie its pretty enjoyable.
Etchy
留言於2008-05-05 2:51PM

xibanyae: yes, that final scene at the end in 'Boston' was hilarious... looks like they just rounded up like 10-15 guys from the nearest street corner in Hengdian...
janechu
留言於2008-05-05 2:18PM [举报]

I still haven't seen it yet... but I still want to see it... =)
xibanyae
留言於2008-05-05 12:32PM [举报]

good choice! the version for china is in full mandarin (*) loses like 30% in jokes and original meanings. things like "that's because you are not listening!" , "don't you have a running monk?", etc... all changed! oh, and of course "come drink with me" was not translatable either.

(*) only the sections in "boston" are in english, all characters but jason and the hop who speak chinese to each other since the beginning of the movie
Etchy
留言於2008-05-05 12:04PM

narom: i guess my point was that because of that, its not very well suited for Chinese audiences despite its cast...
Etchy
留言於2008-05-05 12:03PM

xibanyae: we went to an english screening, they have a cantonese dubbed version too apparently.
xibanyae
留言於2008-05-05 11:51AM [举报]

did u watch it in english and mandarin? or how is it in HK all in cantonese? are u in HK now? ;)
of course this movie is for westerners
Mark Moran
留言於2008-05-05 10:08AM [举报]

The film was originally John Fusco's made-up bedtime stories to his son, sharing ideas from Chinese mythology/culture in a format that his little boy could understand. He later developed the idea into the screenplay, so i guess the idea that it seems made for an American audience makes sense, considering the original audience it was designed for.
shorty
留言於2008-05-05 9:58AM [举报]

Well, I don't have any expectations for the film. I tend not to have expectations for films, so enjoy them much more than most people. My brother's looking forward to it because the American boy is off Sky High. And he liked the jokes shown on whatever he watched (probably a trailer).