! Choose language
選擇你的語言
close  
 Language 

公告

  • If we don't support the movies that deserve it, then we get the movies that we deserve.

BLOG

  • Movie Review: The Forbidden Kingdom

    2008-05-01 11:02PM / 發表 / 會員可以看
    2個評論

    I really, really really disliked this movie.

    Two of the biggest film stars in the world, and 2of the 3 greatest martial arts film stars in history, and we get...

    This?

    It was as if Quentin Tarantino's wet dreams had been put on celluloid.

    Poorly.

    The banal stereotypes, laughably bad dialogue, nonexistent acting and just insulting Orientalism had me cringing the whole time.

    It was as if the people that made this hadn't watched a real Chinese movie made after 1982, a point supported by the opening credits' use of Chinese film imagery from nothing newer than Enter the Dragon.

    The dialogue was more like old English dubs than anything people would really say, and that includes the white kid!

    The fact that it was #1 in the US on its opening weekend just lets us know that no progress has really been made since Breakfast at Tiffany's.

    It was even more special to see a poster for Kung Fu Panda on my way out. How am I supposed to take Vickie to see that movie? At least it will be better than this one...

    This is what America wants to see. A 'China' frozen in the past that exists merely as a means for some white kid to learn how to stand up for himself after being bullied.

    The (white) student who naturally saves his teacher, saves the world  and gets the docile, alluring Chinese girl.

    In both dimensions.

    Forbidden Kingdom was written by John Fusco, the same guy who gave us the classic Hidalgo, where a white guy rides in a desert race in Arabia. SPOILER: He wins... Fusco also wrote the Ralph Macchio classic Crossroads, where a young white guitarist rescues an old black bluesman from prison and eternal damnation. He also wrote Thunderheart, where Val Kilmer, possessed of the requisite vague but pertinent Sioux background, achieves Native American spiritual transcendence in record time under the tutelage of the patient, inscrutable Graham Greene.

    The director of Forbidden Kingdom also made The Lion King, Disney's animated re-make of Birth of a Nation.
    ========================================
    From http://www.wcax.com/Global/story.asp?S=8200239

    "In a way, it's kind of like a kung-fu Wizard of Oz," said Fusco. "A "Wizard of Wu-Shu," if you will.

    This character has entered this world that could well be a dream."*

    *Or a nightmare.

    Fusco's "The Forbidden Kingdom" is the first martial arts movie to open at number one in four years.
    That's a telling statement.
    ================================

    I only watched Forbidden Kingdom because I intend to write an extremely critical piece of research about it.

    I hope Wong Jing makes a movie where I Love You Boyz go back to ancient Palestine and defeat Goliath for David only so that they can learn to stand up to the triad gangs in their neighborhood, making circumcision jokes the whole time.

    That would be just as good, and very likely better.

    No, wait.

    I want Elvis Tsui Kam Kong



    to play the dopey white kid part in a Cat III spoof called The Forbidden Condom.
    ========================================================
    I've tried to be nice, but this movie sucks rancid chicken salad out of a dead cow's ass. With a straw.

    The fact that it caricatures one of the most important legends in the oldest culture on earth is just... extra, I suppose.

    With all that $ TWC is putting into Asian movies, I can't wait to see what's next!

    Oh, I forgot; The Seven Samurai, where the multi-culti (mostly white) band of mercenaries save a Thai village from an evil warlord. John Fusco wrote that one too...

    F@#$ Kurosawa; Weinstein RULES!!!

BLOG評論 (2)

  • 添加評論請先登錄免費註冊
  • seantierney
    藝術家空間 
    留言於2008-05-03 11:56AM
    Fusco's an asshole. A white asshole.

    "Why do Western films always have an Asian girl falling for a white boy (or vice versa)? Doesn't happen! haha."
    Tell me something I don't know. Dammit.
  • peachey
    留言於2008-05-02 3:16AM [举报]
    Most Hollywood films tie-up neatly at the end. And Fusco's smart enough to write something Westerners can follow and want to follow. I think if the film was more true to the real Monkey King and not had a white guy who saves Everybody, fewer people would have interest in it. I knew this going in.

    I think QT wished he had made this movie. He'd have more props, including blood.

    All the secondary characters looked like Fu Manchu, did you notice (who could miss it?)? Aspects of the film disgusted me but I didn't want to get upset over the stereotypes and hijacking of MK tales, the horrible English and dialog fit for an 8-year old (the movie's rated PG13 too).

    Why do Western films always have an Asian girl falling for a white boy (or vice versa)? Doesn't happen! haha.

    2nd weekend's receipt was down over 50% first weekend's box.

所有BLOG 更多BLOG >

统计信息

  • I'd rather be blind than deaf.
  • 職業:  作家樂手演員
  • 年齡: 60
  • 性別:
  • 查看: 745,991

RSS訂閱

Sean Tierney的音樂

聊天板

幫助推廣 Sean Tierney,到網站註冊並加入他/她的粉絲圈,創建你自己的空間、跟其他好友及藝術家交流。