! Choose language
選擇你的語言
close  
 Language 

公告

  • If we don't support the movies that deserve it, then we get the movies that we deserve.

BLOG

  • Mummy Mandarin: A Question

    2008-08-08 9:46AM / 標準BLOG / 會員可以看
    3個評論

    Since all I can say in Mandarin is 'hello,' 'thank you,' and 'shut up' (courtesy of Taiwanese dog owners at 2AM when Fido wouldn't 'mo lun cho')*, I have a Mandarin question for those of who you speak it.

    I have noticed in the last few period films (Warlords, Three Kingdoms, Red Cliff, etc.)  that actors who can speak Mandarin are nevertheless dubbed by others. The explanation has often been that the Mandarin dialect used in the film is 'historically correct,' i.e. significantly different from current Mandarin, so they have to get people who can speak it to record the dialogue.

    Well, I don't think that's the case in The Mummy. It seems like it's (as Dave Chappelle would say) regular-@ss Mandarin.

    Is it?

    I'm certainly not shocked that Hollywood would gloss over linguistic accuracy; I just want to see if my ear actually discerned something.

    My nose sure did.

    * I know it's Cantonese. It was a joke that has obviously miscarried.

BLOG評論 (3)

  • 添加評論請先登錄免費註冊
  • rottendoubt
     
    留言於2008-08-08 2:18PM [举报]
    doh
  • Pickles
    留言於2008-08-08 10:29AM [举报]
    the line you have up there for 'shut up' is actually cantonese.
  • peachey
    留言於2008-08-08 10:22AM [举报]
    I think my Warlords used the actors' voices. Haven't seen the other 2. Don't understand why they'd dub in Mummy - actors can learn lines to say what they're supposed to say....  

    Others - could be their mandarin isn't up to snuff. Like Daniel's in Blood Brothers and The Banquet. haha.

所有BLOG 更多BLOG >

统计信息

  • I'd rather be blind than deaf.
  • 職業:  作家樂手演員
  • 年齡: 59
  • 性別:
  • 查看: 745,418

RSS訂閱

Sean Tierney的音樂

聊天板

幫助推廣 Sean Tierney,到網站註冊並加入他/她的粉絲圈,創建你自己的空間、跟其他好友及藝術家交流。